{"slug":"yzlin286-wq-science-rebuttal-playbook","source_name":"yzlin286-wq/science-rebuttal-playbook","name":"Yzlin286 Wq/Science Rebuttal Playbook","description":"Use immediately after receiving reviewer reports, when a revision decision says major revision, or when you disagree with a reviewer; covers the numbered-response structure, how to split fixable from arguable points, why unprincipled compliance backfires, and how to escalate a genuine disagreement to the editor.","version":1,"lift":{"pass_rate_delta_pts":36.36,"pass_rate_pct":77.3,"total_cases":22,"passed_cases":17,"tokens_delta_pct":90.6,"turns_delta_pct":0,"verdict":"mixed","benchmark_model":"gemini-3.8-flash","grading_method":"judged","completed_at":"2026-11-03T00:14:21.880550+00:00"},"skill_score":0.7727,"benchmark_models":[{"model":"gemini-3.8-flash","headline":true,"delta_pts":36.36,"with_pass_pct":77.3,"without_pass_pct":40.9,"tokens_delta_pct":90.6,"turns_delta_pct":0,"total_cases":22,"cases_aggregated":22,"verdict":"mixed","never_hurt":false,"completed_at":"2026-11-03T00:14:21.880550+00:00","run_id":"25514c4b-6390-4081-b1cd-788c36943d3a","latest_attempt":{"id":"25514c4b-6390-4081-b1cd-788c36943d3a","runner_model":"gemini-3.8-flash","overall_verdict":"mixed","completed_at":"2026-11-03T00:14:21.880550+00:00","gate":null},"version_number":1,"is_latest_version":true,"gate":null}],"trust":{"skill_safety":"passed","safety_status":"clean","intent_verdict":"safe","content_status":"clean","indexable":true},"license":"MIT","install_count":0,"total_uses":0,"total_users":0,"manifest_hash":"24755e4e211414db86f37e4fc43f5c32f6eebe7281e1ed9700d36bb922e68dc7","install_name":"yzlin286-wq-science-rebuttal-playbook","version_id":"1d9164fe-c188-4398-a349-49800c007c20","body_sha256":"24755e4e211414db86f37e4fc43f5c32f6eebe7281e1ed9700d36bb922e68dc7","render_hash":"a6c1bc9c369a59e74708eef95feb50c0471600968d823fae3ecda8ce04000a4d","raw_url":"https://app.decimal.ai/s/yzlin286-wq-science-rebuttal-playbook/SKILL.md","scorecard_url":"https://app.decimal.ai/skills/yzlin286-wq-science-rebuttal-playbook"}